This topic contains 9 replies, has 0 voices, and was last updated by Darren 12 years, 6 months ago.
-
AuthorPosts
-
October 3, 2012 at 7:00 am #101915
Just about to drop the oil out for a change (first one) and the gear oil I bought is called Motorex “Gear Oil 10W/30”.
A quick look in the manual to find the amount to put in and I notice the Husaberg recommended gear oil is called Motorex “Top Speed 4T 15W/50”
Upon checking the place I buy my Motorex from I find that the recommended “Top Speed 4T” is actually 10W/40 ….. there is one called “Formula 4T” which is 15W/50 though.
So …
1/does it matter that I’m about to put in one that is marked 2T and 4T and is 10W/30?
2/ do I always buy 15W/50 as the manual says in future (or immediately if the answer to point 1 “yes, it matters)?Thanks in advance
Confused RazzleOctober 3, 2012 at 7:34 am #230181The gear oil that you have is Fine Razzle
Suzuki recommend 20/50 wt engine oil in the rmx :laugh: Ive used diesel engine oil,Castrol MTX, Auto transmission fluid and am currently using an ELF gear oil in the Gasgas.
Ollie
October 6, 2012 at 10:24 pm #230182Hi Razzle
I am a bit of a novice, but run 4 x 2 strokes for my boys. I use cheaper 4t engine oil and change it regularly. I read some time ago that that the race specific gear oil could be very light and the general engine oil offerred better protection. Important for you to know is that 4t engine oils are designed to run the engine, gearbox and clutch of a 4t, so should run equally as well in just the gear box and clutch of a 2t.
More recently i have been told to run automatic tranmission fluid in 2t gear box. Again on the basis its cheap so use it and change it often.
Further i am told never to use car engine oils as they have friction modifiers which i believe mucks up with your clutch. From my reading some diesel oils dont have friction modifiers in the oil and therefore can make good cheap bike oils. Again on the basis of buy it cheap change it often. Havent tried this one yet.
Good luck with husaberg te300, should be a great ride.
unit
October 7, 2012 at 5:25 am #230385Spot on from the others. I would use what you purchased without a second thought. Different bikes like different viscosity. I stick to motorcycle oils.
October 7, 2012 at 10:30 am #230403I used to use Auto tranny fluid like Dexron III. And change it every 400km or when I started missing gears if before 400km. Considering the stress ATF is designed for our pussy little bike gearboxes don’t bother it.
As others have said, use what you have, it will be fine.
Friction modifiers can mess with your clutch, it isn’t guaranteed, I’ve used a few with modifiers with no dramas. I’m currently using one in the 570 and its fine. Diesel is good stuff too but the detergents they put in them aren’t really helpful for a gearbox application.
October 7, 2012 at 10:45 am #230404axel wrote:Spot on from the others. I would use what you purchased without a second thought. Different bikes like different viscosity. I stick to motorcycle oils.yep i second axel that oil would be fine
October 7, 2012 at 11:05 am #230438Like the others said
Moto’s right friction modifiers can mess with your clutch but you don’t see it much now days because of shared transmission and engine compartments that cars and bikes have has seen oil modifiers change over the last few years . He is also right about the detergents in diesel oil, its good in a dirty combustion diesel but have seen it ruin a few petrol engines (ones with a few miles on already) when switched over and the detergents clean the engine and jam the oil rings up and the engine uses oil. Seen it block an oil filter between Newcastle and Ourimbah. Have seen fibre clutch plates also become gummed up because detergents cleaned the transmission cases the crap had to get absorbed somewhere and in the fibre plates it went. If ran from new its ok like Moto said
IMO got an auto gearbox run auto oil, its made for it. Yes, its designed for higher temps and loads like Moto said then a bike gearbox will ever get to but it isn’t designed for sliding dog style transmissions, auto gear sets are always engaged. All that said lots of people have and do use auto oil without a problem. Berg don’t make oil so if they recommend an oil it’s so their product performs well I would think then everyones happy :blink: .
I have seen many a failure over the years in my job because of incorrect lubricates used, people that seem to think they know better than the people that developed and produced the product especially when I worked at Cat (bloody plant operators eh Pete! :laugh: ). Normally its because people think they are saving money, funny thing is if it’s a bike you would save fark all over a year. Anyway I was taught that oil is cheap and engines, gearboxes, diffs, final drives, hydraulics etc are expensive so thats my dribble.I run Moterex in the two stroke gearboxes here at home, expensive but I cant get the bloody kids to use the clutch once they get moving :pinch:
TB
October 7, 2012 at 3:03 pm #230441I dislike Motorex because when you compare it’s properties to other top level oils that are cheaper it comes out worse off. It’s not a secret KTM are in bed with Motorex, it’s a good oil but it has been subjected to KTM pricing strategy and its just not worth the dollars they ask for it.
As mentioned above using a $10 or $20 cheaper 4L oil represents a puny saving over a years use that it negates buying something cheap. However, there are a few oils that are better AND cheaper than Motorex, so if you’re in this camp why wouldn’t you?
There’s so much hype about oils it isn’t funny, you’d be surprised at the oils a 75MW (around 100,000 horsepower) gas or steam turbine will use spinning at 4,000rpm. The thing weighss hundreds of tons and is several metres long. It isn’t super special high grade shizz and the lube is so important to their operation they have their own lube oil pump and valve trains.
Oils are a minefield, it’s one of the areas where cost does not necessarily mean its better. Look at Penrite HPR Gas10 developed for LPG vehicles, it’s one of the best oils you can buy in just about any area of comparison. Heaps of people in the know use it and it’s not even ‘rated for motorcycle use’.
Realistically, unless you’re using snake oil you’d be hard pressed to see a big difference for a while anyway. The difference between average oils and decent ones is only really evident after 10’s of thousands of KM’s anyway, long after we have gotten rid of them (unless your TB and you just cant let Honda go despite riding a Yamaha and a KTM
)
Manufacturers obviously know their stuff, but does that mean everything they say/recommend is with the best performance intentions of your bike? If you bought a new bike and didn’t make any changes you’d be running 14/45 gearing for ADR compliance, shocking jetting on a 2 banger, not even the best fuelling on a FI 4 banger, crappy tires, springs suited to a 13 year anorexic Asian schoolgirl and an exhaust that restricts power, builds heat and reduces throttle response all in the name of reducing noise. Not to mention air box restrictors, throttle stops, standard duty tubes, 98 RON petrol etc etc, no thanks!
October 7, 2012 at 6:30 pm #230445:laugh: I should have mentioned as well I don’t recommend motorex like Moto said its over priced but the 10 litres I got 2 years ago was free and when it runs out I will go back to Motul. ( that’s just my personal choice mine only Moto)
With reference to the manufacturers and gearing, jetting and suspension people know they build a bike for 20 different countries at 40 different altitudes, for 60 different weight riders to comply with god knows how many different EPA laws world wide while producing to a cost that the average person can afford. That means we get middle of the road that is safe and doest seize and covers their arse everywhere world wide.Anyway back to oils eh
TB
October 7, 2012 at 9:12 pm #230446Tech talk interests me. Its great to see you chime in TB. Its interesting to read Of experiences in other areas of expertise. Your right i think about changing oils late in an engines life. A mate of mine bought a second hand car and after some time decided to run fully synthetic. Bad idea. Similar outcome to your example – cleaned it and killed it. On a trivial note some euro manual car gearboxes have a small wet clutch for reverse. Rexomended oil was Castrol Edge 10w-60.
October 8, 2012 at 1:04 am #230457Thanks everyone, there’s some great knowledge and advice in all that.
I have no idea how to “compare” oil, so recommendation is the best way to go for me.
-
AuthorPosts
You must be logged in to reply to this topic.